Best New York Yankees Games to Rewatch (2026)
Spoiler-free New York Yankees replay recommendations for 2026, ranked by Watchability Score.
1. New York Yankees vs Chicago White Sox
Watchability Score: 92/100
2. Atlanta Braves vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 92/100
3. New York Yankees vs New York Mets
Watchability Score: 82/100
4. New York Yankees vs Boston Red Sox
Watchability Score: 82/100
5. New York Yankees vs Toronto Blue Jays
Watchability Score: 82/100
6. New York Yankees vs San Diego Padres
Watchability Score: 82/100
7. New York Yankees vs Minnesota Twins
Watchability Score: 82/100
8. New York Yankees vs Los Angeles Angels
Watchability Score: 74/100
9. Athletics vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 72/100
10. Cleveland Guardians vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 72/100
11. Los Angeles Dodgers vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 72/100
12. Houston Astros vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 70/100
13. Miami Marlins vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 62/100
14. New York Yankees vs Milwaukee Brewers
Watchability Score: 62/100
15. New York Yankees vs San Diego Padres
Watchability Score: 62/100
16. Detroit Tigers vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 59/100
17. New York Yankees vs Seattle Mariners
Watchability Score: 58/100
18. New York Yankees vs Washington Nationals
Watchability Score: 58/100
19. Tampa Bay Rays vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 58/100
20. New York Yankees vs Tampa Bay Rays
Watchability Score: 54/100
21. Cincinnati Reds vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 54/100
22. Baltimore Orioles vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 54/100
23. New York Yankees vs Chicago Cubs
Watchability Score: 50/100
24. Seattle Mariners vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 50/100
25. New York Yankees vs Texas Rangers
Watchability Score: 42/100
26. Tampa Bay Rays vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 40/100
27. New York Yankees vs Cleveland Guardians
Watchability Score: 39/100
28. Chicago White Sox vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 39/100
29. Houston Astros vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 39/100
30. New York Yankees vs Arizona Diamondbacks
Watchability Score: 39/100
31. New York Yankees vs San Francisco Giants
Watchability Score: 36/100
32. New York Yankees vs Detroit Tigers
Watchability Score: 36/100
33. St. Louis Cardinals vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 36/100
34. New York Yankees vs Houston Astros
Watchability Score: 32/100
35. Tampa Bay Rays vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 31/100
36. Pittsburgh Pirates vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 31/100
37. Baltimore Orioles vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 25/100
38. Boston Red Sox vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 25/100
39. Minnesota Twins vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 25/100
40. New York Yankees vs Baltimore Orioles
Watchability Score: 25/100
41. Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 25/100
42. New York Yankees vs Minnesota Twins
Watchability Score: 25/100
43. Boston Red Sox vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 15/100
44. Texas Rangers vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 15/100
45. New York Yankees vs Kansas City Royals
Watchability Score: 15/100
46. New York Yankees vs Athletics
Watchability Score: 15/100
47. Boston Red Sox vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 15/100
48. Colorado Rockies vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 15/100
49. New York Mets vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 9/100
50. Los Angeles Angels vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 5/100
51. New York Yankees vs Tampa Bay Rays
Watchability Score: 5/100
52. New York Yankees vs Philadelphia Phillies
Watchability Score: 5/100
53. Kansas City Royals vs New York Yankees
Watchability Score: 3/100
Frequently asked questions
What does the Watchability Score mean?
The score runs from 0 to 100 and measures a completed game's entertainment value. Higher scores are stronger replay recommendations, not predictions.
Is this spoiler-free?
Yes. These pages show watchability ratings, not final match scores or winners, so you can choose a replay without learning the result.
How often do rankings update?
Rankings update when newly completed games receive published Watchability Scores. Existing scores remain unchanged; there is no guaranteed update time.