Back to MLB rankings

Best Cleveland Guardians Games to Rewatch (2026)

Spoiler-free Cleveland Guardians replay recommendations for 2026, ranked by Watchability Score.

1. 1. Detroit Tigers vs Cleveland Guardians

   Watchability Score: 82/100

   September 4, 2026

2. 2. Detroit Tigers vs Cleveland Guardians

   Watchability Score: 82/100

   September 6, 2026

3. 3. Minnesota Twins vs Cleveland Guardians

   Watchability Score: 78/100

   July 23, 2026

4. 4. Cleveland Guardians vs New York Yankees

   Watchability Score: 72/100

   June 4, 2026

5. 5. Cleveland Guardians vs Kansas City Royals

   Watchability Score: 62/100

   September 27, 2026

6. 6. Chicago White Sox vs Cleveland Guardians

   Watchability Score: 62/100

   October 5, 2026

7. 7. Chicago Cubs vs Cleveland Guardians

   Watchability Score: 62/100

   April 5, 2026

8. 8. Seattle Mariners vs Cleveland Guardians

   Watchability Score: 62/100

   June 28, 2026

9. 9. Cleveland Guardians vs Los Angeles Angels

   Watchability Score: 62/100

   August 26, 2026

10. 10. Cleveland Guardians vs Tampa Bay Rays

    Watchability Score: 58/100

    October 14, 2026

11. 11. Cleveland Guardians vs St. Louis Cardinals

    Watchability Score: 58/100

    April 15, 2026

12. 12. Tampa Bay Rays vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 58/100

    April 29, 2026

13. 13. Cleveland Guardians vs Philadelphia Phillies

    Watchability Score: 58/100

    May 24, 2026

14. 14. Cleveland Guardians vs Milwaukee Brewers

    Watchability Score: 58/100

    June 18, 2026

15. 15. Cleveland Guardians vs Los Angeles Angels

    Watchability Score: 58/100

    August 25, 2026

16. 16. Cleveland Guardians vs Los Angeles Dodgers

    Watchability Score: 54/100

    April 2, 2026

17. 17. Cleveland Guardians vs Kansas City Royals

    Watchability Score: 54/100

    May 7, 2026

18. 18. Cleveland Guardians vs Minnesota Twins

    Watchability Score: 54/100

    July 9, 2026

19. 19. Cleveland Guardians vs Miami Marlins

    Watchability Score: 54/100

    July 12, 2026

20. 20. San Francisco Giants vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 54/100

    August 20, 2026

21. 21. Toronto Blue Jays vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 54/100

    September 3, 2026

22. 22. Cleveland Guardians vs Houston Astros

    Watchability Score: 50/100

    June 21, 2026

23. 23. Cleveland Guardians vs Tampa Bay Rays

    Watchability Score: 50/100

    July 26, 2026

24. 24. Athletics vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 50/100

    September 20, 2026

25. 25. Cleveland Guardians vs Boston Red Sox

    Watchability Score: 50/100

    September 24, 2026

26. 26. Cleveland Guardians vs Detroit Tigers

    Watchability Score: 42/100

    August 13, 2026

27. 27. Tampa Bay Rays vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 40/100

    October 15, 2026

28. 28. Washington Nationals vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 40/100

    May 27, 2026

29. 29. Chicago White Sox vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 40/100

    July 5, 2026

30. 30. Cleveland Guardians vs Chicago White Sox

    Watchability Score: 39/100

    October 9, 2026

31. 31. Cleveland Guardians vs Tampa Bay Rays

    Watchability Score: 39/100

    October 13, 2026

32. 32. Baltimore Orioles vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 39/100

    April 19, 2026

33. 33. New York Yankees vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 39/100

    June 10, 2026

34. 34. Chicago White Sox vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 39/100

    September 14, 2026

35. 35. Cleveland Guardians vs Toronto Blue Jays

    Watchability Score: 36/100

    April 26, 2026

36. 36. Los Angeles Angels vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 36/100

    May 13, 2026

37. 37. Detroit Tigers vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 36/100

    June 13, 2026

38. 38. Cleveland Guardians vs Chicago White Sox

    Watchability Score: 36/100

    August 9, 2026

39. 39. Chicago White Sox vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 32/100

    September 16, 2026

40. 40. Cleveland Guardians vs Baltimore Orioles

    Watchability Score: 27/100

    September 9, 2026

41. 41. Boston Red Sox vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 25/100

    May 31, 2026

42. 42. Texas Rangers vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 25/100

    July 1, 2026

43. 43. Pittsburgh Pirates vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 25/100

    July 19, 2026

44. 44. Cleveland Guardians vs Cincinnati Reds

    Watchability Score: 25/100

    July 29, 2026

45. 45. San Diego Padres vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 25/100

    August 16, 2026

46. 46. Cleveland Guardians vs Colorado Rockies

    Watchability Score: 25/100

    August 23, 2026

47. 47. Kansas City Royals vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 25/100

    August 29, 2026

48. 48. Cleveland Guardians vs Kansas City Royals

    Watchability Score: 15/100

    September 26, 2026

49. 49. Cleveland Guardians vs Seattle Mariners

    Watchability Score: 15/100

    March 29, 2026

50. 50. Kansas City Royals vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 15/100

    April 8, 2026

51. 51. Cincinnati Reds vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 15/100

    May 17, 2026

52. 52. Cleveland Guardians vs Minnesota Twins

    Watchability Score: 15/100

    September 13, 2026

53. 53. Cleveland Guardians vs Athletics

    Watchability Score: 13/100

    May 3, 2026

54. 54. Arizona Diamondbacks vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 13/100

    August 2, 2026

55. 55. Chicago White Sox vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 9/100

    October 11, 2026

56. 56. Houston Astros vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 9/100

    April 22, 2026

57. 57. New York Mets vs Cleveland Guardians

    Watchability Score: 5/100

    August 6, 2026

Frequently asked questions

What does the Watchability Score mean?

The score runs from 0 to 100 and measures a completed game's entertainment value. Higher scores are stronger replay recommendations, not predictions.

Is this spoiler-free?

Yes. These pages show watchability ratings, not final match scores or winners, so you can choose a replay without learning the result.

How often do rankings update?

Rankings update when newly completed games receive published Watchability Scores. Existing scores remain unchanged; there is no guaranteed update time.